Corporate Governance Practices in Startups: Challenges and Opportunities

Introduction: Governance in the Startup

Contracts form the backbone of commercial transactions and many personal arrangements in India. From supply agreements and service contracts to leases and employment terms, parties rely on contractual promises to plan conduct and manage risk. A breach of contract occurs when one party fails to perform obligations undertaken under a valid contract, either wholly or in part, or performs them in a manner not contemplated by the agreement.

Indian law treats breach of contract as a civil wrong with defined legal consequences rather than a moral failing. The primary framework is contained in the Indian Contract Act, 1872, supplemented by the Specific Relief Act, 1963, and procedural statutes such as the Limitation Act, 1963. Together, these laws determine when a breach occurs, what remedies are available, and how losses are assessed.

Understanding breach of contract is essential for law students, contract managers, and small-business owners alike. Clear knowledge helps in identifying risks early, responding effectively to defaults, and drafting contracts that reduce disputes. This article explains the concept of breach of contract under Indian law, its types, legal effects, remedies, and practical steps to handle and prevent breaches, using plain language while maintaining legal precision.

Types of Breach of Contract

Indian law recognises several ways in which a contract may be breached. Classification helps determine the appropriate remedy.

Actual Breach

An actual breach occurs when a party fails to perform contractual obligations on the due date or during performance.

Illustrative hypothetical:
A supplier agrees to deliver machinery on 1 June but fails to deliver on that date without lawful excuse. This constitutes an actual breach.

Anticipatory Breach

An anticipatory breach arises when a party, before the time for performance, clearly indicates an intention not to perform or makes performance impossible (Indian Contract Act, 1872, s. 39).

Illustrative hypothetical:
A contractor informs the client in writing, two months before completion, that work will not be finished due to internal reasons. The client may treat the contract as terminated immediately.

Minor (Partial) Breach

A minor breach involves deviation from contract terms that does not defeat the core purpose of the agreement. Remedies are usually limited to compensation.

Fundamental (Material) Breach

A fundamental breach goes to the root of the contract, depriving the aggrieved party of the main benefit. Such breach often justifies termination and broader remedies.

Essential Elements of Breach

For a legally actionable breach, certain elements must generally be established:

Existence of a valid contract (Indian Contract Act, 1872, ss. 10–11).
Obligation under the contract that is clear and enforceable.
Failure to perform or defective performance by one party.
Resulting loss or legal injury to the aggrieved party.

Where performance becomes impossible due to supervening events beyond control, the doctrine of frustration may apply (Indian Contract Act, 1872, s. 56), providing a statutory defence rather than a breach.

Anticipatory Breach in Detail

Section 39 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 permits the promisee to terminate the contract when the promisor refuses to perform or disables performance before the due date. The promisee may either:

Accept the repudiation and treat the contract as terminated; or
Continue with the contract, keeping it alive until performance is due.

The Supreme Court in Hochster v. De La Tour principles (English authority followed in India) has influenced Indian courts in recognising anticipatory breach as actionable. Indian decisions have consistently applied Section 39 where repudiation is clear and unequivocal.

Legal Effects and Defences

Effects of Breach

Upon breach, the aggrieved party may claim remedies such as damages, specific performance, injunction, rescission, or restitution, depending on the nature of the contract and breach.

Common Defences

A party accused of breach may rely on defences such as:

Frustration or impossibility (s. 56)
Consent or waiver by the other party
Prior breach by the claimant
Limitation under the Limitation Act, 1963

Claims for breach are typically subject to a three-year limitation period from the date the breach occurs (Limitation Act, 1963, Articles 54–55).

Remedies for Breach of Contract

Indian law emphasises compensation rather than punishment. Remedies aim to place the aggrieved party, as far as money can, in the position that would have existed had the contract been performed.

Damages

Damages are the most common remedy (Indian Contract Act, 1872, s. 73). Compensation is limited to losses that naturally arise in the usual course of events or that were within the contemplation of both parties at the time of contract formation.

The Supreme Court in Hadley v. Baxendale principles (adopted in India) governs remoteness of damages. Indian application is seen in Kailash Nath Associates v. DDA, Supreme Court, 2015 (citation to be verified), which clarified that damages must reflect actual loss unless contractually pre-estimated.

Liquidated Damages and Penalty

Section 74 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 deals with stipulated sums payable on breach. Indian courts distinguish between:

Genuine pre-estimate of damages (enforceable); and
Penalty clauses (court awards reasonable compensation, not automatic recovery).

In Fateh Chand v. Balkishan Dass, Supreme Court, 1963 (citation to be verified), it was held that proof of loss is relevant, and courts must award reasonable compensation.

Specific Performance

Specific performance is an equitable remedy compelling actual performance of contractual obligations. It is governed by the Specific Relief Act, 1963. After amendments in 2018, specific performance is more readily available, subject to statutory exceptions (Specific Relief Act, 1963, ss. 10, 14).

This remedy is commonly granted in contracts relating to immovable property, where damages are inadequate.

Injunction

Courts may grant injunctions to prevent ongoing or threatened breaches, especially in negative covenants (Specific Relief Act, 1963, s. 38).

Rescission and Restitution

In cases of serious breach, the aggrieved party may rescind the contract and seek restitution of benefits already conferred (Indian Contract Act, 1872, ss. 39, 65).

Calculation of Damages

Damages are calculated based on:

Foreseeability of loss at contract formation
Causation, linking breach to loss
Certainty, avoiding speculative claims

Courts avoid awarding punitive or exemplary damages in contract law, except in exceptional statutory contexts.

Mitigation of Loss

The aggrieved party has a duty to mitigate losses, meaning reasonable steps must be taken to reduce harm resulting from the breach. Failure to mitigate may reduce recoverable damages (Indian Contract Act, 1872, s. 73).

Illustrative hypothetical:
If a buyer cancels a supply contract, the seller must attempt resale in the market instead of allowing losses to accumulate unnecessarily.

Practical Steps After a Breach

Review the contract terms, including termination and dispute resolution clauses.
Document the breach with dates, communications, and evidence.
Issue a formal breach notice.
Consider mitigation measures promptly.
Seek legal advice before terminating or initiating proceedings.

Sample Breach Notice (Illustrative Template)

Date: [●]
To: [Name and Address of Defaulting Party]
Subject: Notice of Breach of Contract dated [●]
This notice records failure to perform obligations under Clause [●] of the above contract. The breach consists of [brief description]. Remedial action is required within [●] days, failing which legal remedies may be pursued without further notice.
Sincerely,
[Name / Designation]

Drafting Tips to Reduce Breach Risk

- Clearly define obligations, timelines, and deliverables.
- Include termination and notice-and-cure provisions.
- Draft liquidated damages clauses carefully as genuine pre-estimates.
- Specify dispute resolution mechanisms (arbitration/litigation, seat, and governing law).
- Maintain written records and variation procedures.

Conclusion

Breach of contract under Indian law is a structured and principled area designed to balance commercial certainty with fairness. The Indian Contract Act, 1872 and the Specific Relief Act, 1963 provide a coherent framework for identifying breaches and awarding appropriate remedies. Understanding types of breach, available defences, and practical response strategies enables parties to manage disputes efficiently and reduce legal risk. Careful drafting and timely action remain the most effective safeguards against contractual breakdowns.

Disclaimer - The blog is for informational purpose and does not constitute legal advice, consult a qualified lawyer for case specific guidance.

About

We provide comprehensive legal and professional services designed for accuracy and integrity. Our team streamlines complex documentation and research, allowing you to focus on your core objectives.

Professional services and legal support firm dedicated to simplifying paperwork, compliance and day-to-day documentation.

Quick Links

Disclaimer: Legal services are provided in accordance with applicable laws and regulations. Court appearances and specific legal opinions are handled by registered advocates; Shree Sudarshan does not claim to be a law firm unless duly registered as such in the relevant jurisdiction.